Here is my story in a nutshell...
Ulcerative Colitis showed up in my early 20's. I battled it with Prednisone & other meds for 12 years. In 1998, at age 32, I had had enough. I met with a surgeon & he explained the "S-Pouch" to me. I thought..."This sounds GREAT!!!" I understood I would never have "normal" bathroom habits - but even cutting my 15-20 visits a day in half would be a vast improvement. The surgeon told me it may take up to a year for my new pouch to work properly - I could live with that. He removed my entire colon & looped my small intestine into an "S-Pouch" & gave me a temporary ileostomy while my new internal pouch healed. I spent 12 horrible weeks with my temp ileo & could not wait to get rid of it. After the "S-Pouch" had healed, they "re-attached" my plumbing & I thought most my problems would be solved....
WRONG!!!!!!
For me - the "S-Pouch" was worse than having the UC!!! Chronic pouchitis set in early on & I was put on daily antibiotics. I had to take (4 times a day) Imodium, Lomotil & Metamucil to slow down & firm up my stool. The meds didn't help much & I had constant leakage from my rectum which lead to the worse case of diaper rash known to mankind!!! (You know it's bad when the doctors & nurses gasp in horror when they take a look

!) I had so many accidents & I felt sick all the time. I never thought it was possible to spend anymore time in the bathroom than I had with the UC -
WRONG AGAIN! I lived in the bathroom!
After 8 LONG years - that was enough!!!! Last September, at age 40, my wonderful husband talked me into having a permanent ileostomy. (I had it done on his birthday - great present, huh?)
I feel so foolish to have waited & wasted those 8 years! I do not regret trying the "S-Pouch", as I would have always wondered, "what if"? However, I do regret waiting so long to surrender to the permanent ileostomy.
I now have a great life!!! I no longer live in the bathroom, no more pain, no more diaper rash (thanks to my "Barbie Butt"), no more meds & all in all - my ileostomy has given me a life I never thought possible.
In conclusion - it is my understanding that the "S-Pouch" is just like the "J-Pouch" - only shaped a little different. The reason I started this thread was curiousity. I had mine done in Iowa (1998) & my fellow ostomate had his done in Nebraska (1989) & I was wondering if it was a "Midwest" thing?
Here are some thoughts from my fellow (former) "S-Poucher":
"I think that the "S" pouch was just an early and not too successful design of the "J" pouch that didn't work very well because of the extra scarring and the early version of the valve (I guess it is a valve) at the bottom end."
"If I remember what he (the surgeon) told me the "S" pouches had a much longer "neck" between the pouch and where the poop came out. Early thinking was that the longer neck would provide better control but in reality it just caused more problems."
Thanks for reading -any stories or comments would be appreciated,
Lori